Tuesday, October 17, 2023

On Call Back Mountain (1997)

      The name Eve Bunting and the promise of a story about wildlife prompted me to pick up On Call Back Mountain. The painting of two children and a dog on the cover drew me in. But wait--that's not a dog. It's a wolf. 

      Barry Moser did create stunning illustrations for this picture book about . . . what? I couldn't quite comprehend the story. It's a loosely connected series of events with minimal closure. We meet two young boys on their farm at the bottom of Call Back Mountain. Bosco visits in June on his way up to the fire tower. He's accompanied by two mules, Aida and Traviata. There's reference to "the fire a few summers ago that drove the wolves away, the wolves and coyotes and the other animals, too." This fire was deliberately set, but there's no follow up to help the reader cope with such an evil act. We skip over that inconvenience to Bosco's promise that the forest will soon be thick and healthy again. 

     Bosco heads on up the mountain. He and the family exchange light signals each night. "All through the summer we send out good nights across the darkness, and it's as if Bosco is still with us. Until, one night no light answers ours." Yes, he's dead. 

     At the end of the story, the children see a wolf. "That wolf had the longest, skinniest legs." (Unlike the canine on the book cover.) And that's it. Bosco promised that the wolves would return. They have. The howl of a nearby wolf is supposed to be comforting considering the abrupt death of Bosco. 

     This story felt unfinished to me. Like a beaded necklace an artist didn't have time to complete, I'm left wondering if Eve Bunting was going to miss a publishing deadline if she'd worked on this story a bit more. 



Super-Completely and Totally the Messiest (2001)

     Super-Completely andTotally the Messiest by Judith Viorst is brilliantly illustrated by RobinPreiss Glasser. The text leaves lots of room for interpretation, and Glasser’s joyful, curly-haired, redhead protagonist brings the words to life. We meet young Sophie on the cover. She drops books and rain gear on the floor with an  enthusiasm that evades the question of who will clean up.

     This story has a subtle rising action, but no obvious beginning, middle, and end. It’s just a story of how Sophie manifests messiness by showering joy everywhere—and on everything. Glasser shows how Sophie can create a mess while carrying a plate that holds a piece of chocolate cake—we can’t look away because it’s slapstick comedy. Sophie’s family doesn’t scold her. They ask her to try: try to be neat, to be careful, to pay attention. But Sophie forgets. And we forgive.

     This book is read aloud online by Lyons Learning Lab.

     My Picture Book Talk for this story is here.

Saturday, September 23, 2023

The Art Lesson (1989)

     In The  Art  Lesson, we learn that Tomie dePaola needed to advocate for himself in school. Before he entered kindergarten, young Tommy aspires to be an artist. “He drew pictures everywhere he went.” His family honors his drawings by displaying them at home and at work. Grandma Fall River puts one in a  frame  alongside special family photos. But school is different.

    Kindergarten doesn’t have an art  teacher. When his first-grade teacher distributes small boxes of crayons, she says not to “break them, peel off the paper, or wear down the points”! So Tommy eagerly anticipates his first art  lesson with the school art teacher. But wait—the art teacher instructs the class to copy her drawings. “Copy? COPY?” Tommy must speak up. His talent and skill require special  consideration.

     I love how the pictures and text in this book complement each other. Story details are first implied and then revealed several pages later. My personal favorite is the realization that Tommy’s many drawings have colors only possible using the eight crayons in a  regular box. He doesn’t receive a box of 64 colors from his family until first grade.

 

This story is read aloud on Learn With Me Mrs. Sullivan.

My Picture Book Talk for this story is here. 

This lesson is read aloud on my YouTube channel.

In Coal Country (1987)

         Judith Hendershot’s In Coal Country has a matter-of-fact style that reads like nonfiction. There’s no plot, just memories of the land, the work, the play, and the family life in a coal camp in the 1930s.  Hendershot shares little emotion, so Thomas B. Allen’s illustrations cannot reveal them. Mostly, the people in each scene come in second to the landscape and the coal operation.

     I wanted this book to show childhood in a mining town from the perspective of youthful innocence and joy. It does not. Instead, the book presents scenarios with little warm nostalgia. As I searched for background knowledge, my hope faded. Consequently, there are two lessons for this book. Lesson 1 addresses only the explicit text. Lesson 2 challenges mature readers to ask questions about the life behind the text and face some harsh reality. Lesson 2 includes many links for background knowledge. This book is packed with opportunities for research and conversation. 

     This book is read aloud online by the Puskarich Public Library Coal Museum Videos

    My Study English lesson for this book is here.

Smudge, the Little Lost Lamb (1991)

     Smudge, the Little Lost Lamb by James Herriot (1991), takes readers on an emotional roller coaster ride. When little Smudge leaves his field, he encounters a snarling dog, enormous bull, speeding traffic, and bitter cold weather. A young girl saves the bedraggled Smudge at the end of his adventure, and the lamb learns that the world holds loving kindness. Ruth Brown’s gorgeous two-page spreads illustrate the countryside of the Yorkshire Dales, United Kingdom.

     Yet, Herriot invites deep thinkers to expand upon a superficial reading when he identifies Smudge as the kind of lamb who isn’t  “happy until they’ve found a way out of the field.”  Smudge plays with his peers just fine, but he becomes bored. He doesn’t run away from home; rather, he seeks the whole world to explore. “Oh, the sensation of freedom was wonderful. . .” Given Smudge’s exceptional nature, what do we make of the ending: “He would never ever try to get out of the field again.” ?

This story is read aloud online by Storytime with Will.

My Picture Book Talk for this story is here. 

Wednesday, September 20, 2023

Jake the Philharmonic Dog (2006)

     Jake the Philharmonic Dog, by Karen LeFrak, parallels environmental sounds with instrumental. In this way, Richie and his dog Jake build readers a bridge to the  symphony. Marcin Baranski’s illustrations of Jake will appeal to younger children. Since her only human characters are adults, this book is also accessible to older readers. LeFrak interprets the sounds in our surroundings as music. When Jake barks, he’s in conversation with these sounds, and he plays his part in a natural orchestra.  He associates the music of the woodwind section with birdsong he’s heard in the park. The percussion section reminds him of thunder and sends him running circles in fear. When the string section calms Jake, we realize the author has conveyed the emotional power of music.

This story hints at the narrative and evocative elements of classical music, which music teachers could expand upon. In the fall of 2022, the “grand concert hall” we see in this book reopened as the David Geffen Hall. The New York Philharmonic’s new space and updated programming give us all a new opportunity to enjoy the symphony.

This story is read aloud online by Morgan McWethy.


"Slowly, slowly, slowly," said the Sloth (2003)

      The book "Slowly, Slowly, Slowly," said the Sloth  by Eric Carle reminds us that slow is OK. The sloth is a slow-moving creature in a world where every other creature moves quickly. Even a turtle passes by, its gradual travel faster than the sloth. Yet the sloth is perceptive and self-confident. We’re pleasantly surprised and impressed with the sloth's answer to his neighbor’s question. Its usual silence conceals a wealth of knowledge and deep self-respect. Children who identify with the sloth will experience validation. Children who move quickly through the world will gain insight – seeing the world from someone else's perspective.

 

This story can be found at Art with Ms. Steratore.

This is a revised version of a previous lesson for this book.

Three Little Kittens (2010)

Three Little Kittens by Jerry Pinkney (2010) is for children who like looking at kittens. That’s about it. There is no story here. In this ...